Jails/ Prisons: India
The administration of jails
2014, 2016 statistics
See graphics including ‘Total number of central and district prisons’ and ‘Sanctioned strength and vacant positions in jails.’
Confinement of criminals in a cell illegal: HC
CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana high court has held that confining hardcore criminals in a cell for 22-hours in a day and releasing them only for two hours is “impermissible and illegal” and added that a prisoner remains a person and cannot be reduced to an animal-like existence.
“The quasi-solitary confinement is held to be illegal and violative of the rights guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution… Such treatment completely discards the rehabilitative aspect of the punishment, which is a major component in the philosophy of sentencing in every developed society,” observed the high court and directed the prison authorities in Punjab to change their current practice.
Justice Sudhir Mittal passed these orders while hearing a bunch of petitions filed by several jail inmates confined in Punjab’s Bathinda jail. The HC took up the petition filed by dreaded gangster Chandan, alias Chandu, who has been confined in Bathinda jail and challenged his solitary confinement for violation of his right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. On its part, Punjab informed the HC that various directions have been issued for the maintenance of discipline and control in the jails. These directions are legal and valid, it added.
HC asks Punjab to apprise it of latest confinement measures
Narrating details of several riots inside the state jails, Punjab informed the HC that it held meetings on December15, 2020 and February 23, 2021, in which it was decided to adopt greater security measures and shift 42 hardcore or notorious prisoners to Bathinda Central Jail. After hearing both the parties the HC sought a report about the situation in jail and found that each of the petitioners is being confined in a separate cell for 22 hours daily and is released from respective cells for one hour in the forenoon and one hour in the evening.
The high court also found that an inmate is confined in the first part of the cell from sunset to sunrise and for the remaining part of the day, except for two hours, in the second part of the cell. For all this period, he has no company except for the odd prison staff who comes by on rounds. The prisoner is not able to see any other human being and thus, conversation with fellow beings is out of the question. There is no facility of a common mess. Except for one hour in the morning and one hour in the evening, the inmate is all by himself with his solitude and there is no limit on this.
“Such confinement is not strictly solitary confinement but can be called quasi-solitary because the inmate is deprived of the human company for extended lengths of time and such confinement has been held to be extremely harsh and violative of basic human rights which remain the entitlement of every prisoner,” observed the HC and added that it could not be justified even on grounds of maintenance of discipline and order and curtailment of crime.
“The prison administration can surely come up with suggestions which would make the custody conform to the law of the land while meeting the security concerns. For example, the identified prisoners could be housed in separate barracks instead of cells where provision is also made for messing. Members of rival gangs could be confined in different barracks and the system of staggered lockouts could be retained. Confinement to cells is restricted from sunset to sunrise and the period of lockouts be increased, however, within the confines of high-security zones. The final decision, of course, would rest with the prison administration, but is always open to judicial scrutiny,” added the HC.
Adjourning the matter for July 19, the HC has asked Punjab to inform it about the fresh measures it intended to adopt on the issue.
Crime inside jails
India Today, February 3, 2016
Bihar's jails are the new nerve centres of crime, offering a safe haven for gangsters to operate from.
In June 2015, the authorities at Sheohar divisional jail allowed a strange, joint "register entry", a process allowing undertrials to visit the jailer's office to deposit money. The people involved were an under-trial couple-kidnapping accused Puja and her gangster husband Mukesh Pathak-and, according to prison records, they parked some Rs 15,000 rupees with the office. But that wasn't all they were doing there. With the authorities looking the other way, the two apparently used the assistant jailer's office to pursue "physical relations". Only a select few, the top bosses of Sheohar jail, knew of the arrangement. But the fact was outed when, during a regular medical check-up in September, the doctor declared Puja pregnant. While the Sheohar jail officials tried to hush it up, it couldn't go on forever. Once the name of Mukesh Pathak-now roaming free after his daring escape last year-surfaced as the main accused in the December 26 killing of two engineers at Darbhanga, the police started digging deeper. Soon, the details of his in flagrante proclivities in jail tumbled out.
The prisons in Bihar have always had an unsavoury reputation, but of late things have taken a turn for the worse. Many known criminals now rush to surrender in the courts after committing a crime, which suggests they find the going better in jail than on the run. And what's not to like? Jails are safe havens, and since they have surrendered, it prevents confiscation of property and makes it easier to post bail. In September 2014, a joint report of the DM and the SP in Sitamarhi revealed how a select group of prisoners was allowed to avail facilities like ACs, coolers and mobiles. Even marijuana and liquor were provided to the "privileged" ones, it said. All this when the number of CCTV cameras have gone up, jails are less crowded, and the media is more active than ever. None of this has acted as an deterrent. And while the report did raise eyebrows, it has been conveniently buried. Take the Mukesh Pathak case, for instance. Pathak married Pooja in Sheohar jail in October 2013, after obtaining prior court permission. Jailer R.N. Shafi had then played the role of the girl's father and even performed the kanyadaan. Last year, after the jailer's office incident, the groom complained of medical issues and was promptly shifted to the government hospital in Sheohar from where he escaped on July 20 after drugging his guards. The irony here is the resultant inquiry did not even question the doctor who recommended him to hospital nor those who 'treated' him there for a week. (You can't blame the doctors either. In 2011, jail Dr Buddhadeo Singh was beaten to death in Gopalganj district jail after he refused to issue a fake medical certificate. According to latest NCRB figures, Bihar jail inmates made 7,051 visits to hospitals for "medical reasons" in 2014.) It's been four months since Puja's pregnancy was detected in September 2013, and an 'internal probe' is yet to conclusively establish anyone's guilt. IG prisons Prem Singh Meena says the probe has revealed "three dates when the couple could have had a private meeting (leading to her pregnancy). One such day was when they visited assistant jailer's office. The assistant jailer, head warden and warden of Sheohar jail have been served a show cause notice. We will take action once we get their response". Jha's gang is not an isolated example. Bihar's jails are the new hunting ground for criminals on the make. One of the reasons is also the low conviction rate. When it comes to percentage share of prison inmates, Bihar today has the lowest share of convicts (14.2%) against undertrials (85.6%)- the national average ratio is 31.4% convicts to 67.6% undertrials. This is also indicative of another fact. The number of arrests has gone up, and so has the number of police cases. But one of the worst conviction rates in the country means it is no deterrent to major crime. (In fact, criminals prefer the jail route nowadays than taking the police head-on. In 2001, the number of police 'encounter' deaths in shootouts stood at 41. The number dropped to two in 2015.) All this breeds a vicious circle. Once the police arrest a hardened criminal, he is produced in court that remands him to judicial custody. But, once the accused reaches jail, he starts operating with impunity from there. It leads to a horrific conclusion: higher the arrests, higher the crime. So it holds true that the jails-headed by a pliant gang of prison officials-have defeated the very purpose for which they were created. Bihar's jailed bahubalis are as active in this as your common variety don. In 2015 itself, independent MLC Ritlal Yadav, MLA Anant Singh, former RJD MP Shahabuddin have all had fresh FIRs filed against them for "jail violations". Leader of the Opposition, the BJP's Prem Kumar, says, "A majority of criminal cases committed in Bihar are linked to jails. Prison officials are either being pressured or are hand-in-glove with inmates. CM Nitish Kumar mans the home portfolio, he has to set things right fast or admit the situation is outside his control."
Killings ordered from jail
The Darbhanga murders of the two engineers, Brajesh Kumar Singh and Mukesh Singh, happened after their Gurgaon-based construction company, currently building a 120-km stretch of the Begusarai-Darbhanga state highway, refused to pay extortion money. The project, nearly halfway through, is worth Rs 700 crore. Police sources say the construction company was asked to cough up 10 per cent of the project cost as extortion money. The killings, which immediately put a question mark on the fate of big ticket projects in Bihar, and the investigation trail, led the police to another jail. Santosh Jha, mastermind of a flourishing extortion racket in Bihar and Mukesh's boss, was cooling his heels in Gaya central jail. Jha was in touch with hitmen via mobile phone and issuing elaborate orders via Facebook messenger, one of which was to bump off the two engineers. The extortion cell
Santosh Jha, 40, an ex-Maoist-turned-criminal, has over a dozen cases of murder, extortion, kidnapping and one of even 'landmine explosion' against him. He's believed to have extracted several crores from some of the major construction firms in Bihar. One of the new breed of tech-savvy criminals, Jha operates under the facade of a 'People's Liberation Army', which targets road contractors in north Bihar and affluent businessmen of Nepal. He mostly enrols his castemen as gang members and is said to have collected levies from over 1,000 people in north Bihar and Nepal. At least, six engineers have been killed in Bihar in the past for not caving in to the demands of the gang. Though Jha, who was arrested from West Bengal in June 2014, was lodged in Gaya, it was his influence which helped Pathak lord it over the Sheohar jail authorities. Police investigations have revealed that besides being in touch with gang members through FB, Jha even paid a fixed salary to his seven sharpshooters using net banking. Seized documents so far pertain to 25 bank accounts belonging to Jha's shooters. A dozen ATM cards belonging to gang members have also been seized. This is not a problem relating just to the Jha gang. Despite repeated recommendations, the prisons department is yet to instal jammers in any of Bihar's 58 jails while all agree that inmates using mobile phones has emerged as the single biggest reason for the spurt in crime. This also explains why Chief Minister Nitish Kumar's zero tolerance against crime has failed to have the desired effect in Bihar. K.C. Tyagi, Rajya Sabha MP and JD(U) spokesperson says, "The government has taken note of the rising criminal incidents with links to jails in Bihar. Nobody, including jail officials, will be spared if found guilty of irregularities." All the talk, though, will have to backed up by action. Considering Bihar's history and the spurt in violent crime in the last six months, that'll be no easy task.
Use of cellphones in jails
The Hindu, December 4, 2016
Gautam S Mengle
For the affluent and well-connected jailbird, incarceration can come with all mod-cons, including liquor, drugs and even visits to dance bars. Most importantly, he is allowed to stay in touch with his underlings with his own mobile phone.
Police officials, both serving and retired, say the first thing convicts from organised crime syndicates do behind bars is set up a system that allows them to get whatever they want.
The well-oiled supply chain includes family, fellow gang members, lawyers, and prison staff willing to help — for a price. With the prisons department being understaffed and underpaid, that last crucial link isn’t hard to set up. Retired Crime Branch officials say this was at its peak in the 90s, when gangs like Dawood Kaskar’s ‘D-company’ and the Chhota Rajan gang were the most active.
The Arthur Road Central Jail in Mumbai, which housed most accused from the gangs, was divided into camps, mirroring gang memberships. Ambadas Pote, retired Deputy Commissioner of Police, calls it the nalli nihari racket, a dish of slow-cooked meat along with the bone marrow. Chuckling, he explains: “Family members of inmates with gang-land connections, with due permission of the court, would send tiffin boxes containing nalli nihari to the prison. Unknown to the staff, a SIM card wrapped in plastic would be stuffed inside the bone, which the inmates would remove and use. Cell phones, on the other hand, would be smuggled inside by bribing prison staff.”
When the racket was discovered by the Crime Branch around 10 years ago, it led to raids in several prisons and suspension of prison staff. Needless to say, inmates quickly found new ways to get the SIM cards.
“Court appearances are a boon for inmates when it comes to smuggling in SIM cards,” says a senior Mumbai Police officer.
“In crowded courts it is easy for anyone to slip a SIM to an inmate, and they’re easy to conceal and very easy to get rid of if there is a surprise check by prisons officials. And it’s equally easy to get a new one.”
Though the present day gangs are pale shadows of the groups that ruled the city — with dons and leaders either dead, serving life sentences, in exile or retired — SIM cards are still one of the items most frequently smuggled into prisons because they need to be changed frequently to make it harder for law enforcement to detect their use. Upgraded jail infrastructure, including CCTV cameras and surprise checks by vigilance teams, seems to have done little to stop the smuggling racket.
Active and undetected
Three recent incidents highlight the ineffective preventive measures.
• In 2013, gangster Abu Salem was allegedly shot at by Devendra Jagtap, the main accused in the murder of Mumbai-based advocate Shahid Azmi. This was when both were prisoners inside a jail. Jagtap fired two shots before being overpowered by prison guards, and Salem sustained an injury to his right hand. The fact that a gun and ammunition had been smuggled in to Jagtap shook the Prisons Department, leading to a search and departmental inquiry.
• In May 2013, Mumbai-based builder Rajaram Manjaokar was shot at in Borivali. The Mumbai Crime Branch arrested three men. The three confessed that they were operating on orders from Yusuf “Bachkana” Kadri, a Chhota Rajan lieutenant, who had organised the attack because Manjaokar had refused to pay extortion money. Bachkana was, at the time, a prisoner in Hindalga Central Jail, Belgaum. He was subsequently transferred to a central jail in Bangalore and several Hindalga officials were suspended.
• In 2015, three mobile phones were found in Taloja Central Jail, in the cell of Ravi Mallesh Bora alias D.K. Rao, another Chhota Rajan aide. His call data records revealed that he had made over 500 calls from those numbers in six months, a large chunk of them to international numbers. Rajan, who had been arrested a month earlier, had been on the run during this period and Rao is suspected to have kept in touch with him through these calls.
Additional Director General of Police (Prisons) Bhushan Upadhyay accepts that inmates getting access to cellular phones and running their gangs from inside jails is a reality despite efforts to prevent them. “We keep conduct regular surprise checks in central central jails to look for any such activities,” he said.
“Whenever such a case comes to light in our checks or through other channels, we take strict and immediate action against any prison staff who are found to be involved.”
The Times of India, Jul 24, 2015
Put all prisons under CCTV camera surveillance: SC to govt
Amit Anand Choudhary
In a landmark verdict to ensure protection of human rights of prisoners, the Supreme Court on Friday directed the Centre and all state governments to put prisons under surveillance of CCTV cameras.
A bench headed by Justice TS Thakur also directed the states which have not set up Human Rights Commission to form the panel as soon as possible. There are many states and Union Territories like Himachal Pradesh, Meghalya, Nagaland, Arunachal Pradesh, Delhi, which have so far not set up the human rights watchdog panel. The court also asked the state governments to consider installing CCTV camera in police stations and lock ups to ensure that people are not subjected to unnecessary torture. It also directed that there must be two women constable in each police station.
Deaths in the jailhouse: the extent of the problem
1994-2014: Deaths within the prison premises
The Hindu, September 27, 2016
Preventing death in custody
While the liberty of a person in custody can be curtailed according to ‘procedures established by law’, it cannot be stretched to extinguish life.
From 1995 to 2014, 999 suicides were reported inside Indian prisons. Tamil Nadu alone has seen 141 of them. The State houses less than 4 per cent of the country’s prisoners, yet it accounts for 14 per cent of suicides inside prisons. With such a poor track record, the State machinery should at least deliberate possible solutions.
Is Tamil Nadu the bad apple or is the entire orchard rotten? Data show that in the last 20 years, three inmates on average have been found dead daily in Indian prisons. In 2014, there were five deaths every day, so 35 deaths in a typical week. Two of these deaths were suicides. In the same period, the death rate inside prisons rose by 42 per cent. Ninety per cent of these deaths were recorded as ‘natural’, but what constitutes ‘natural’ in a custodial set-up is questionable.
Violation of rights
The numbers show that the prison department is ill-equipped to protect the health and safety of inmates. Little public scrutiny in jails provides the possibility of violation of basic rights. It is only when violations result in deaths that questions are raised, and even then only cursorily.
This perfunctory attention to prisons helps overlook the fact that deaths are the consequence of the everyday reality of prison life. Inmates live in despair of little or no contact with the outside world, are denied the basic desires to eat or wear clothes of their choice, to forge relationships. They wait for basic medical needs, their movements are restricted, and they are frustrated as they know nothing about their cases. As they are not taken to court often, they miss the chance of meeting a judge, their lawyers, and families. There is also lack of a mechanism to hear their complaints.
And this is just the tip of the iceberg. As an undercover operation in Uttar Pradesh’s Kasna Jail showed recently, abuse takes place in prisons. Extortions, corruption, and torture are common.
The only way to thwart what goes on in these institutions is to make them accountable. Prison monitors are mandated to regularly visit jails, listen to prisoners’ grievances, identify areas of concern, and seek resolution. These visitors include magistrates and judges, State human rights institutions, and non-official visitors drawn from society.
However, an upcoming Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative study (CHRI), ‘Looking into the haze — a study on prison monitoring in India’, shows that not even 1 per cent of Indian jails are monitored. In Tamil Nadu, according to recent media reports, most prisons await appointment of non-official visitors. As per National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) figures for 2014, just 500 inspections were made across the 136 jails in Tamil Nadu, perhaps by the official visitors. This means that there were less than four inspections per jail in an entire year.
The Supreme Court in 2015 ordered the Centre and the States to install CCTV cameras in all the prisons in the country. CCTV cameras serve two purposes: they bring on record incidents that could otherwise be suppressed, and play a preventive role in violation of rights, as the fear of facing consequences for the same would increase under vigilance.
Suicide is a critical problem in prison complexes — in the last 20 years, the suicide rate (suicides per lakh population) in prisons is recorded at 15.4. A person is 1.5 times more likely to kill himself or herself inside jail than outside it. In Tamil Nadu prisons, the suicide rate is higher than 40.
Providing counselling to inmates is crucial for them to deal with the ordeal they undergo in custody. But are prisons prepared for this? Tamil Nadu prisons have only sanctioned 105 correctional staff. Less than half the positions are filled. Out of the 13 psychologists sanctioned, only eight have been hired. With around 16,000 prisoners, this translates to one psychologist for every 2,000 inmates.
After Ramkumar’s death, the DG (Prisons) announced that a magisterial inquiry will be ordered. But does that mean anything? The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has expressed concern in the past about post-mortem reports “appearing to be doctored due to influence”. There is no information in the public domain about the details of these reports, whether the magistrate visited the death scene, what evidence was gathered, the time taken for the inquiry, the outcome, and whether prison officials were charged or found guilty.
The prison department is mandated to report all cases of custodial death to the NHRC within 24 hours of their occurrence. But the prison department data collated by the NCRB and the NHRC data don’t match. Also, almost half of the unnatural deaths in prisons are reported as ‘others’ by the NCRB. It is important that these ‘others’ be demystified.
While the liberty of a person inside custody can be curtailed according to “procedures established by law”, it cannot be stretched to extinguish life itself. The NHRC has repeatedly issued guidelines to prevent and respond to custodial deaths. It is time for the State governments to start taking these guidelines seriously. If the state works to promote communication between the inmate and his family and lawyer, increase conjugal visits, ensure adequate trained prison staff, and open up the prison to civil society, we might be able to save some lives. If not, we know who is responsible for the next suicide inside our jails.
By Anon, The Times of India, 12 March, 2013
“Unnatural” deaths: 2013
The Times of India, Jun 12 2015
10 unnatural deaths occur in Indian jails every month
The murder of an inmate in Tihar is no isolated incident, with official data showing that there were 115 “unnatural deaths“ in India's jails in 2013, the latest year for which data is available from the National Crime Records Bureau. That's about 10 unnatural deaths every month. At 5.9 unnatural deaths per 10,000 inmates, Delhi's jails clock more than twice the national rate of 2.8 per 10,000 inmates. Whether this has anything to do with Delhi jails having over twice as many inmates as they are supposed to hold, against a national average of 118% occupancy, is a moot question.
The NCRB's prison statistics in India 2013 shows that of the 115 deaths due to unnatural causes, more than half (70) were officially classified as suicides, 12 were attributed to “assault by outside elements“ and eight to murders by inmates.With one execution and one death due to firing, the causes of deaths of 23 “others“ have not been spelt out.
The highest rates of unnatural deaths (per thousand inmates) were in Jammu & Kashmir, Tamil Nadu, Assam, Delhi and Rajasthan in that order. The lowest rates among bigger states were in undivided Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Odisha, Maharashtra and Jharkhand. The prison statistics also show that barring Chhattisgarh, a state severely affected by Maoist insurgency , Delhi had by far the most overcrowded jails in the country . Chhattisgarh had 15,840 inmates in its jails which had a capaci ty of just 6,070, thus recording an `occupancy rate' of 261%. Delhi's 13,552 inmates were stuffed into jails meant to hold 6,250 people, an occupancy rate of 217%.The national average occupancy rate was about 118%, which shows that while jails as a rule are overcrowded in India, Delhi's prisons are almost twice as congested as the average.
UP, 2010-16: One prisoner dies every 26 hours
AGRA: On an average, one prisoner dies in Uttar Pradesh every 26 hours. According to the state prison department's response to an RTI query, more than 2,050 prisoners have died in Uttar Pradesh since 2010.
Human rights activist Naresh Paras, who filled the RTI application, has witten to the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC), governor of UP and the PMO to take up the matter.
According to the response to the RTI query (a copy of which is with TOI), 2,062 prisoners died in a period of 74 months from January 2010 to February 2016. Out of them, more than 50% were undertrials. As many as 44 prisoners had committed suicide between 2010 and 2015. Around 24 died in police custody or allegedly got murdered.
"Age and natural causes behind the death of prisoners is just another excuse to escape the reality. The situation inside UP prisons is pathetic. There is a major lack of medical treatment for inmates and poor infrastructure at prison clinics. The state government and prison authorities have no concern for prisoners' rights. The atmosphere inside the prisons provokes convicts to commit suicide. Protection of priso ners is the prime responsibility of prison authorities, yet murders and unnatural deaths in jails and police custody continue to take place on a frequent basis," Paras told TOI on Sunday.
In 2010, 322 prisoners died. Out of these, half a dozen killed themselves, one died in police custody and six were murdered. In 2011, 285 prisoners died, including an undertrial from Pakistan.
There was an increase in the number of deaths in 2012, with 360 recorded, including another Pakistani undertrial. Three inmates killed themselves. In 2013, 358 prisoners died, while 345 lost their lives in 2014. This was follo wed by 345 deaths in 2015 and 53 in the first two months of 2016.
Inspector general of police (IG) GL Meena said, "Several initiatives have been taken in the past to provide better facilities to prisoners. Deaths reported due to old age and illness is quite normal and inevitable. The situation in prisons has improved in the past few years, but the number of prisoners has also increased. The state government is getting new prisons constructed. This will reduce overcrowding and help in developing better infrastructure. Efforts will be made to control the number of unnatural deaths of convicts."
Deaths in the jailhouse and the law
Unnatural deaths in jails be compensated: SC
Holding that prisoners cannot be treated as “chattel“ (personal possession) and are entitled to a fundamental right to health that must be upheld by governments, the Supreme Court expressed concern on Friday over unnatural deaths in jails and directed that families of all such deceased inmates be compensated.
A bench of Justices Madan Lokur and Deepak Gupta ruled that family members of prisoners who died under mysterious circumstances in the last five years are eligible for compensation and entrusted high courts to take note of such cases from 2012 onwards and award an adequate sum. The court also passed a slew of directions to the Centre and states to im prove conditions for jail inmates to provide basic facilities, including medical assistance, in 1,382 prisons in the country. It said the Centre must encourage family members to visit jailed relatives and explore the possibility of permitting contact through phones and video conference.
The court noted that conditions in Tihar jail were also pathetic as it was not equipped to face any emer gency situation as there was a shortage of doctors and other medical staff ranging from 18% to 62%. “If these are the conditions in what is perhaps the `best prison' in the country, we shudder to think what the position would be in other prisons across the country ,“ the bench said.
As per the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), 552 prisoners died an unnatural death between 2012 and 2015.They died due to various reasons, including suicide, murder by jail inmates and negligence by jail staff. The court noted that the National Human Rights Commission had, from time to time, passed various directions to state governments but they were not followed, resulting in the continuance of unnatural deaths of prisoners.
“No state government can shirk its duties and responsibilities for providing better facilities to prisoners. If a state government is unable to do so, it should be far more circumspect in arresting and detaining persons, particularly undertrial prisoners who constitute the vast majority of those in judicial custody . Governments and the prosecution do not have to oppose every bail application nor do they have to ask for the remand of every suspect pending investigation,“ the bench said.
“If the fundamental right to life and liberty postulated by Article 21 of the Constitution is to be given its true meaning, the central government and the state governments must accept reality and not proceed on the basis that prisoners can be treated as chattel,“ it said.
Expressing concern that there is no let-up in custodial deaths, the court said the situation reflects a tragic state of affairs indicating disdain of the state towards the life and liberty of individuals, particularly those who are incarcerated.
Deaths in the jailhouse: causes
Retributive policy in jails to blame
Highlighting a complete mismatch in approach towards prisoners by the criminal-justice system and prison administration, the Supreme Court has said this dichotomy could be a major cause of large number of unnatural deaths of jail inmates every year.
“What is practised in our prisons is the theory of retribution and deterrence and the ground situation emphasises this, while our criminal justice system believes in reformation and rehabilitation (of prisoners) and that is why hand-cuffing and solitary confinement are prohibited,“ said a bench of Justices Madan B Lokur and Deepak Gupta.
Justice Lokur, writing the judgment for the bench, said the rejection of criminal justice system-advocated reformation and rehabilitation policy by the prison authorities has resulted in “violence in prisons and eventually unnatural deaths“.
The SC quoted National Crime Records Bureau statistics to highlight large number of unnatural deaths in In dian prisons -127 deaths (87 suicides) in 2012; 114 (70) in 2013; 195 (94) in 2014 and 114 (77) in 2015. “The average suicide rate in prisons is over 50% more than the the figure in normal conditions,“ it said.
The court said: “The common person does not violate law for no reason at all. It is circumstances that lead to a situation where there is a violation of law. On many occasions, such a violation may be of a trivial nature or may be a one-time aberration and, in such circumstances, the offender has to be treated with some degree of humanity . At least in such cases, retribution and deterrence cannot be an answer to the offence and the offender. Unless the state changes this mindset and takes steps to give meaning to life and liberty of every prisoner, prison reforms can never be effective.“
If the over 100 unnatural deaths in prisons every year was a cause of worry for the SC, it also doubted adequacy of facilities, including health care, leading to large number of natural deaths in jails -1,345 in 2012; 1,482 in 2013; 1,507 in 2014 and 1,469 in 2015.
The SC said: “No state government can shirk responsibilities for providing better facilities to prisoners.If a state government is unable to do so, it should be far more circumspect in arresting and detaining persons, particularly under-trial prisoners... The state government and the prosecution do not have to oppose every bail application nor do they have to ask for the remand of every suspect pending investigation.“
It also asked the women and child development ministry to “discuss with concerned officers of the states and formulate procedures for tabulating number of children who suffer an unnatural death in child care institutions where they are kept in custody. Necessary steps should be taken by December 31“.
Uttarakhand HC ends solitary confinement/ 2018
The Uttarakhand high court abolished the practice of keeping convicts on death row in isolation immediately after the sentence is pronounced, adding that solitary confinement was a “cruel practice which amounts to torture and can cause immense pain, agony and anxiety” to inmates.
“The convict shall not be segregated till the sentence of death has become final, conclusive and indefeasible, which cannot be annulled or voided by any judicial or constitutional procedure,” the bench said.
The division bench of justices Rajiv Sharma and Alok Singh said that the period to keep a convict sentenced to death in isolation should be for the shortest possible time — two to three days before execution of the sentence. This should be done only after the convict has exhausted all the possible options to the highest levels, including an appeal in the SC as well as mercy petition to the President, the bench said.
The court said that the practice was in violation of Article 21 of the Constitution that guarantees protection of life and personal liberty, and Article 20 (2) which says that no person shall be prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once. The bench held that isolating the convict was an “additional punishment” and amounts to “torture and violation of his basic human rights”.
Economics and jailhouse economy
Vocational training of prison inmates is an important step in rehabilitating convicts. Last year (2015), around 17% of the 4,19,623 prisoners were trained in various crafts, including carpentry, weaving and tailoring (PRISONERS IN TAMIL NADU ARE THE MOST PRODUCTIVE, HERE'S WHY, Nov 10 2016 : The Times of India)
See graphics, including ‘Value of goods produced by prison inmates in India, statewise, in 2014,’ ‘Annual expenditure inside jails’ and ' Value of goods produced by jail inmates...'
As in 2018
A first of its kind survey on how foreign prisoners are faring in Indian jails will be carried out over the next six months by Vellore-based Academy of Prisons and Correctional Administration (APCA). The country’s 1,412 jails house over 6,000 foreigners, about 1.5% of the total prison population. Half of the foreigners are undertrials.
The survey came to be, in a new diplomacy of sorts, when the British High Commission in Delhi along with Australians and those from embassies of the US, Canada and New Zealand suggested APCA take up the study. A recentlyheld round table at Delhi British High Commission paved the way.
“We discussed maintaining contact with family in their home countries, sometimes language difficulties, differences in diet, understanding the prison system in a foreign country,” Ed Bossley, UK consul to India told TOI on mail.
The study will survey differences in language, food, access to medications and meeting families. “We will interview foreign prisoners and submit a report to the Union home ministry,” Beulah Emmanuel of APCA said.
The snatch of non-south Asian prisoners — from Africa, Europe, Australia and the Americas — are likely to be deeply impacted by Indian diets and language barriers in the country’s jails. For the Japanese convict in Goa, the eight Chinese undertrials in a Bihar prison, or even the 149 Nigerians in Delhi’s Tihar, food can be an issue. Standard fare in Tihar, believed to be among the country’s better jails, is roti, sabzi, dal, rice and curd. As of July 2019, there were more than 450 foreign prisoners in Tihar spanning around 50 nationalities: Peru to Taiwan, Venezuela to Vietnam. Among recent highprofile undertrials in Tihar is Christian Michel, accused in the Agusta Westland chopper scam. Most of the prisons except in the east and south serve only vegetarian fare. The representatives discussed differences in food, and a suggestion was made to provide food as per diet.
Language is among key issues foreign prisoners face, Emmanuel said. The diplomats sought to know about facilities for translators in prisons as “their countrymen imprisoned in India face tough problems due to language barriers”. The diplomats also sought to know if foreign inmates could be segregated and housed separately, given the “cultural differences”.
Another crucial point is access to medicines. It is an ordeal for foreign inmates to get medicines prescribed by doctors in their home countries. On this, the consuls urged if the government could allow medicines be ordered online from their nation of origin.
The gap between foreign prisoners and families back home will be surveyed as it is near impossible for relatives of inmates to meet them virtually or personally. Travel is expensive and a suggestion was made to allow video calls.
Commenting on the near-absence of communication of foreign inmates with families, prison authorities said the manual is common for all and each state has its own rules. Facility “cannot be recreated for foreign prisoners” alone. “If they need provisions, they should approach court. A former minister convicted in a graft case moved court to install an air-cooler in Jodhpur’s central prison,” said R K Saxena, retired director of the Justice Mulla Committee, constituted to assist government formulate prison reform. He said there was barely any facility for foreigners to be in touch with their families as most prisons do not have international call facilities.
Prison officials have so far visited jails in Amritsar, Delhi and Patiala, and met inmates from Kenya and other African countries.
Tuberculosis: a 2022 study
New Delhi : Prisoners in India are five times more at risk of developing tuberculosis (TB) than the general population, a first-of-its-kind study to assess prevalence of the communicable disease in prisons across the world has found.
According to the study, published in The Lancet Public Health, the incidence of TB in Indian prisons is 1,076 cases per100,000 inmates. In the general population, TB incidence is 210 per 100,000 population, according to WHO TB report 2022.
“Overcrowding and lack of ventilation is a known cause of high incidence of TB in prisons. To prevent this, authorities should conduct regular health screening,” Dr Raj Kumar, director, Vallabhbhai Patel Chest Institute, University of Delhi, said. In the latest study, which looked at the incidence of TB among prisoners in 193countries, researchers found that 125,105 of the 11 million people incarcerated globally developed TB in 2019 — a rate of 1,148 cases per 100,000 people per year; significantly higher than the global incidence rate among all persons, 127 cases per 100,000 people per year. However, the case detection rate was just 53% of all TB cases in prisons globally, the study published in The Lancet Public Health found. Furthermore, the researchers found astrong relationship between country-level tuberculosis incidence rates and overcrowding in prisons.
Leonardo Martinez, study lead from the School of Public Health, Boston University, US, said, “This connection between TB and overcrowding suggests that efforts to limit the number of people who are detained may be one potential public health tool to combat the TB epidemic in prisons. ”
Luxury, mostly illegal
Sunetra Choudhury on some high-profile cases
It was sometime in early 2016 that I got a call from an undisclosed number. The woman on the other end of the line had a foreign accent and when she told me her name was Anca, it took me only a couple of seconds to figure out who she was.
I was a little confused because the last I heard about Anca Neascu Verma was that she was in jail for various CBI [Central Bureau of Investigation] cases along with her husband, Abhishek. ‘Oh, you are now...,’ I asked.
‘Yes, I am now outside,’ she finished what I was trying to say, and I could sense her smiling. This sense of humour warmed me a bit, though I was intrigued because while I had reported on CBI and a few of cases that involved her and her husband, I had not shown any particular interest in cases which were more obsessively followed by defence beat reporters.
I had never spoken to either of them but I was in touch with their lawyers for legal developments. So when she suggested we meet at Hyatt one afternoon, I thought it was perhaps some lead to a story, so I agreed. I wasn’t really sure what I was going to gain from it but the fact that she sought me out soon after coming out of prison, had me curious.
‘I’m feeling so good because I just went to the spa after so long,’ she declared when she saw me. She looked almost six feet tall and was striking with her blonde hair and a fitted designer dress. ‘I tell people that I was at an ashram. That’s what I call my four years in jail – ashram.’ I was fascinated to say the least. I guessed she had called me to make a case for her husband who was still in jail at the time. I knew she wanted me to perhaps do stories on what had happened to the CBI's investigation after so many years, but what we ended up talking about was her time in jail. I have done stories on jail experiences throughout my career, but never before had I got this kind of insight into prison life.
Anca was rich, beautiful, a Romanian married to an influential Indian businessman who was forever being chased by law authorities, and she was now sitting outside jail, literally cooling her pedicured heels and willing to dish the dirt on what goes on inside. Till now we only had an inkling of what may be happening inside through sporadic news headlines — Mohammad Shahabuddin being caught taking selfies with his phone inside prison, the Punjab jailbreaks revealing that they had been updating their Facebook status from inside the jail till the time they ran away, the Nirbhaya rapist committing suicide in jail.
Each of these news breaks would quickly be hushed away by a spokesperson, like a statement ordering an inquiry, and then everything would get brushed under the carpet again. For the first time, I was meeting a woman who had been in the slammer and was willing to talk about how she figured out the system to her advantage.
So I fixed a TV interview with Anca where she shocked audiences by revealing that well-off women inside jail, like her, hired servants for a fee. The servants, also inmates, would do all their menial tasks for meagre amounts of money, which meant that you could spend your jail term at least not worrying about cleaning the toilet and doing any other task assigned to you.
It would have ended with that — a good interview and a good TV show — but when she sent me a picture of herself wearing Louis Vuitton inside jail, it was beyond my imagination. She said that it wasn’t for publication but there were a whole series of pictures taken like that which I couldn’t get off my mind.
The CBI may be calling her a con woman but Anca told me something which I found very honest: ‘If you steal 1,000 rupees, the hawaldar will beat the shit out of you and lock you up in a dungeon with no bulb or ventilation. If you steal 55,000 crore then you get to stay in a 40-foot cell which has four split units, internet, fax, mobile phones and a staff of ten to clean your shoes and cook your food (in case it is not being delivered from Hyatt that particular day) – Incredible India!’
None of these things she could say on camera but she was willing to give me all the information. How she managed to live with an LCD TV and Star World Premiere, not missing a single episode of ‘Orange is the new Black’ inside jail. That’s when the idea of a book occurred to me and I decided to look for others like Anca, who are basically so influential that they didn’t mind telling us what really happens in our jails. If they hid their own comforts of how rules were bent for them, they didn’t hesitate to talk about others and, in return, the others filled in on their jail antics.
Initially, getting people to talk was tough. For instance, in Dasna Jail, Rajesh and Nupur Talwar had clearly figured out a survival system. One of the first things that struck me during our meeting at the superintendent’s room of the jail was how nicely ironed their kurtas were. They were both stunned with the prospect of spending their lives incarcerated for their teenage daughter Aarushi’s murder, but they didn’t have to worry about laundry, apparently. Neither of them had also lost any weight even though at that time, they had already spent more than a year at Dasna.
This had always intrigued me. How could most affluent people manage to not look any different despite being in jail? Indrani Mukerjea was an exception in being the rich TV executive whose blow dried long bob soon became all-roots exposed grey mass, but people like A Raja, Sanjay Dutt and others came out betraying no sign of change.
The reason, in Talwar’s case at least, was evident. They were doctors and the jail officials were delighted to have their services in house. So they had traded in their skill in servicing the jail staff and their families in return for a relatively comfortable life inside. But the problem was talking to me about it would only jeopardise their interests.
Then there was the case of Saharasri Subrata Roy. The Supreme Court may have sent him to prison in 2014 for not paying back his depositors Rs 20,000 crore, but they had also given him benefits which had never been seen by anybody in prison before. Subrata Roy is the first person in the history of Tihar Jail to have comforts of air-conditioning.
Whether you are A Raja, Pappu Yadav, Manu Sharma or Sanjeev Nanda, the best you could have in luxury was a cooler, tiled floors and a cell to yourself which you could furnish with a bed. But because the court allowed Roy to use the video conference facilities, he was moved from Ward 9 of Jail Number 1 to the old court complex of Tihar Jail. It had meeting and conference rooms and because it was meant to be like an office, it had air-conditioning too. ‘Even Indira Gandhi didn’t have this comfort when she came to stay here.’
Excerpted with permission from Behind Bars: Prison Tales of India's Most Famous (published by Roli Books)
2018: video calling facility
Women prisoners and inmates of open jails across Maharashtra can now make video calls to their families and relatives, said a senior official of the prison department of the state government.
This could be the first-ofits-kind initiative for prisoners in the country, claimed the official. Under the initiative, the prison department has started a smart video calling facility for inmates lodged in women’s jails and open prisons, the official said.
A prisoner can talk to his/ her family members for five minutes and is charged Rs 5 for availing the service, he said. “It was initiated on a pilot basis at the Central Prison at Yerawada in Pune and now it has been started in women’s jails and open prisons across the state,” he said.
Through the video calling facility, prisoners can speak to their relatives or family members for five minutes on a given day on mobile phone numbers registered with the department, he said. The whole conversation is monitored by a police constable to ensure the video chat centres only around family issues , he said. Earlier, the department had installed coin box phones inside jails to enable inmates to speak to their family members.
Jails in UP, MP, Chhattisgarh most crowded
Deeptiman.Tiwary @timesgroup.com New Delhi
The Times of India Aug 19 2014
Overcrowding of prisons is often cited as the reason for inmates living in pitiable conditions. However, official data show prisons in almost 20 states have less number of inmates than their official capacity or are just at par.Actually a few states, including UP , MP, Chhattisgarh and Delhi, have skewed the national average with massive overcrowding their prisons.
UP alone contributes to overcrowding by close to 32,000 prisoners when cumulative overcrowding across the country stands at close to 42,000. In its 65 jails with a capacity of 47,518 inmates, UP has crammed 80,311. Chhattisgarh is another laggard state with its prisons overcrowded by 8,930 inmates against a capacity of 5,850. Delhi, whose Tihar jail has often been in the news for overcrowding, has almost twice the number of inmates against its capacity . Madhya Pradesh jails, from where six SIMI accused broke free last year, are overcrowded by over 7,000 inmates.
Curiously , Bihar is one of the best performing states along with Tamil Nadu in building optimum capacity in jails. While TN has almost 9,000 less occupancy against a capacity of 21,951, Bihar over 6,500 less inmates against its total capacity . Odisha is another state where prison capacity has improved over the years with almost 30% less occupancy against capacity
Much of these positive changes have come about in the past one decade when the Centre launched seven-year scheme worth Rs 1,800 crore for modernization of prisons. i In 2002, there were 1,135 jails t across the country with a capacity to hold 2,29,874 inmates.However, 3,22,357 inmates were t crammed in these jails. Between 2002 and 2012, number of jails increased to 1,394 with the capacity improving to 3,43,169.By the end of 2012, there were 3,85,135 inmates in these jails.
While number of inmates increased by close to 50,000 in this period, the capacity of prisons improved by over 1 lakh easing pressure on infrastructure and making life better inside jails.
Occupancy rate: 2013-17
The occupancy rate and inmate population of Indian jails: 2013-17
India and the world: Prison population
Jun 15 2015
With 716 prisoners per lakh of people, the US has the world's highest incarceration rate. Among 190 countries for which data is available, India is ranked 183rd in terms of the incarceration rate. This rate is dependent not just on the crime rate, but also on urbanization, efficiency of the criminal justice system and marginalization of some sections.Thus, there is a huge difference in incarceration rates among coloured and white people in the US. In India, Muslims, Dalits and tribals constitute 53% of the prison population -much higher than their share in the population.
Judicial intervention to curb overcrowding
The Hindu, October 14, 2016
SC says jails are overcrowded by 150 %, laments plight of inmates
“Fundamental rights and human rights of people, however they may be placed, cannot be ignored only because of their adverse circumstances”
Blaming Delhi for paying “little or no attention” to the fundamental rights of under trials and convicts, the Supreme Court said it is “not only tragic but also pathetic” to find that prisons in the national capital, along with half a dozen States across the country, are overcrowded by over 150 per cent.
A Bench led by Justice Madan B. Lokur, in a judgment on a suo motu Public Interest Litigation (PIL), observed that prisons are crammed with inmates by over one and a half times the permissible limit.
“Fundamental rights and human rights of people, however they may be placed, cannot be ignored only because of their adverse circumstances,” the judgment observed.
Action not taken The recent judgment refers to jails in Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, Karnataka, Kerala, Maharashtra, Assam, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan in this context, while observing that it was “unfortunate that in spite of directions by the Court, the prison authorities have not been able to take any effective steps for reducing overcrowding in jails”.
The court found that authorities have defied repeated orders of the Supreme Court — the latest ones being on February 7 and May 5 of this year — to draw a “viable” plan of action to de-congest jails. Instead, prison authorities have banked on ad hoc proposals like the construction of additional barracks or jails, and these proposals have no time limits for implementation.
Besides, the Court also found that the Ministry of Women and Child Development is yet to frame a Manual for Juveniles in Custody under the recently amended Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015.
The Supreme Court directed the Ministry to get the manual ready by November 30 and present it in court. It also ordered the Ministry of Home Affairs to receive and collate plans of action for de-congesting jails from the various States and Union Territories in the next six months. Moreover, the SC directed the government to prepare a viable Plan of Action within the next six months and hand it over to the apex court by March 31, 2017.
“We are a little distressed to note that even though this Court has held on several occasions that prisoners, both undertrials and convicts, have certain fundamental rights and human rights, little or no attention is being paid in this regard by the States and some Union Territories, including the National Capital Territory of Delhi,” the judgment observed.
2017: 10 states have more that 200% occupancy
The Times of India, Oct 11 2017
States with jails that have over 200% occupancy; Number of prisoners in the 149 jails, state-wise
The Model Prison Manual 2016 quotes Supreme Court judgments that held that a person in prison doesn't become a non-person and is, therefore, entitled to all human rights within the limitations of imprisonment. But overcrowding in jails is a serious concern, and Parliament was recently informed that there are 149 jails in India that are holding more than double their capacity of convicts
Indian prisons are stretched to their limits
In 2021, the crisis was most acute in Uttarakhand, Uttar Pradesh and Delhi where the occupancy rate crossed 180%
A news report published in The Hindu on Sunday described how the Border Security Force (BSF) in the North 24 Parganas district of West Bengal is handing over illegal migrants with a clean record to Bangladeshi officials as prisons are overflowing in the State. If normal procedure were to be followed, these illegal migrants would have been lodged in correctional homes, the report added.
The story has put the spotlight back on the age-old problem of overcrowded prisons in India. Data show that in 2021, the latest year for which numbers are available, over 5.54 lakh people were lodged in prison, while the total capacity of Indian jails was about 4.25 lakh. This means that the occupancy rate of Indian prisons was 130%, a peak at least in the last decade.
Chart 1 shows the capacity of Indian prisons, the number of actual prisoners and the occupancy rate in the last decade. While the capacity has increased from some 3.32 lakh to 4.25 lakh in the last decade — a 27% increase — the number of prisoners has shot up from 3.7 lakh to 5.54 lakh in the same period — a 48% increase. This imbalance has caused the occupancy rate to surge from 112% to 130% in the last decade.
The pan-India problem of overflowing jails has worsened in the last decade. However, it was most acute in three northern States/Union Territories — Uttarakhand, Uttar Pradesh, and Delhi. In these three regions, the occupancy rate crossed 180% in 2021 (180 prisoners for every 100 vacancies). Notably, in these three regions, the occupancy rate ranged between 60% and 75% in 2011. In fact, of the 36 States and UTs analysed, the occupancy rate increased in 26 of them in the past decade. And in 18 of them, the occupancy rate in 2021 was more than 100%.
Chart 2 shows the occupancy rates of select States/UTs in 2011 and 2021. The highest increase was observed in Delhi, where the occupancy rate increased from 60% to 183% — a 122% point increase. Among the major States, significant decreases were observed in Chhattisgarh and Punjab where the occupancy rate decreased by 108% points and 51% points, respectively.
Bangladeshi nationals dominate the foreign inmate population in India. Most foreign inmates are lodged in West Bengal prisons as the State shares a long border with the neighbouring country.
Chart 3 shows the foreign inmates lodged in West Bengal jails as a share of total foreign prisoners. While there is a slight dip in recent years, the share has consistently remained above 30%. The chart also shows the share of Bangladeshi undertrials among the total number of foreign undertrials lodged in Indian jails. The share has remained above the 35% mark in recent years.
When read along with the fact that the occupancy rates in West Bengal prisons have increased from 70% to 120% in the past decade, the BSF’s recent decision to hand over illegal migrants to Bangladesh appears justified.
While on the one hand, jails are overflowing, on the other, the vacancies for prison officers are alarmingly high in some States. Also, the money spent on each prison inmate varies widely across States. Chart 4 plots prison officer vacancy in 2019 against the amount spent per inmate in ₹ in 2019-20. In Uttarakhand, Chhattisgarh, Bihar and Jharkhand over 60% of officer positions were vacant. And in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Punjab and Maharashtra, less than ₹20,000 was spent on each prison inmate in 2019-20.
Cases where prints were developed from crime scene, 2021-22
VIP treatment in prisons, 2017
See graphic. VIP treatment in prisons
Prisoners as labour workforce
The Times of India, Apr 24 2016
Private sector goes to prison
Jail inmates are fast emerging as the new labour workforce for India's private sector. Is it corporate opportunism, penal reform, or a bit of both? In the 21st century marketplace that makes much of the back story of a product, here's a twist: the football, floor tile, shampoo, or car you own could have featured a prisoner in the workforce. The Indian prison industry -manufacturing for the state or making prison-branded goods so far -has lately started working for the private sector. From The Himalaya Drug Company and automotive component manufacturer Spark Minda Corporation, to small manufacturers in Meerut in UP and Yamunanagar in Haryana, the private sector has started outsourcing -or in prison parlance, `in-sourcing' -jobs to jails.
Himalaya's supply chain for alfalfa, a medicinal plant that it uses in several health products, can be traced to a prison farming programme established five years ago in Karnataka Open Air Jail, Bengaluru. It was later extended to three prisons in Andhra Pradesh and two in Goa. “Forty-five percent of our Alfalfa requirement is sourced through contract farming, of which about 3% comes from the Prison Farming Programme,“ says Himalaya CEO Philipe Haydon. “Our goal is to source the entire alfalfa requirement from this programme.“
Three months ago, 20 prisoners in Colvale Central Jail, North Goa were trained by the pharma's field staff in farming and harvesting.They're paid the state's daily prison wage of Rs 120 for skilled labour (Rs 80 for semi-skilled work). Himalaya provides the seeds and manure, and buys back the harvest, which varies from 6.5 to 8 metric tons per prison annually, at an undisclosed price.“Now that we're earning some revenue, we plan to expand such partnerships and scale up wages,“ says Elvis Gomes, Goa's IG, prisons. And so 10,000 square metres in Colvale and Sada Sub Jail have been set aside for the project.
Late last year, 30 inmates at Pune's Yerwada Central Jail were recruited by Spark Minda, which started an assembly unit for automotive wiring harnesses there, after its successful operation in Tihar the year before. “We borrowed the idea from our counterparts in Germany who employed prisoners,“ says N K Taneja, Group Chief Marketing Officer. The company currently employs 80 inmates across both correctional facilities, but believes there's room for at least 200. “Before we got into this partnership, we ran it by our clients, Maruti Suzuki and Mahindra & Mahindra who approved of the initiative,“ he says.
For optimal results from their two-month training, Spark Minda only hires convicts in for the long haul -five years and more. While all prisoners get a certificate of work, Yerwada's inmates earn Rs 200 a day, part of which goes to the prisoners' welfare fund and the institution itself, and Tihar's get the standard wage of Rs 110. Tihar also earns a separate monthly rent of Rs 12sq ft from Spark Minda for use of their premises.
Meanwhile, in Yamunanagar District Jail, 200km from Gurgaon, two dozen inmates produce ceramic floor tiles for a local firm. “They work six to eight hours a day for Rs 40,“ says IG Jagjeet Singh, adding that Ambala Central Jail produces steel furniture for another company .
Indian prison officials speak glowingly of the PPP model -also interpreted as the Private Prison Partnership -saying its income offsets costs. (In 2014-15, the 88,221 inmates lodged in UP prisons cost the state Rs 74 lakh.) But the model also assists in rehabilitation by skilling prisoners for life beyond bars.And finally , as per prison wisdom, a `busy convict is an easy convict'.
Prison brass say convicts are never pressed into work, although they may be nudged. “We first select people who know the work, then bring in those interested but unskilled,“ explains DIG prisons, Telangana, V K Singh. The assembly of electric metre boxes for Hyderabadbased Linkwell Telesystems, and steel furniture for SS Industries are in-sourced to the central and open prisons in Cherlapalli.
“We vet companies for security risks, potential environmental pollution, risk to prisoners' health, their business plans, and other factors. We have valuable land and we don't want firms that only wish to take advantage of our real estate,“ Singh maintains. Not to mention captive labour. The prison-industrial complex worldwide has been under greater scrutiny in recent years.Contracting companies in China and America have been condemned for their exploitative prisoner wages (as low as 2 cents an hour) -and for profiting off the taxpayer, as prisons are usually state funded.Moreover, companies don't have to worry about absenteeism or health benefits and pension.
Nikhil Roy , programme development officer at the London-based Penal Reform International, believes there's nothing wrong with the profit motive. “It's the exploitation of prisoners that we need to guard against. Hence, the Mandela Rules (the UN's recently revised standard minimum rules for the treatment of prisoners) do not rule out profit but make it clear this should not be “subordinate“ to the welfare of the prisoners,“ Roy says on email.
The conservative view has long argued that prisoners don't deserve market minimum wages because the state sponsors their bed and board anyway . Also, their crime or alleged crime denies them equal wage rights. So income, however paltry , ought to be regarded as a bo nus. But the reformist view is that even prisoners have families to supt port outside, and a decent income earned in incarceration will not only help their kin, but also give them a sense of purpose and dignity .
(In some cases in Tihar, 25% of the convict's income is remitted to the family of his victim).
But even though companies are less wary of their association with prisons today, calling it their CSR, jail authorities know they still have to tread lightly. “If we strike too , hard a bargain on remuneration, companies will stay away,“ points out V K Singh. Kiran Bedi, former IG prisons, Tihar is credited with planting the PPP model in Delhi prisons in the '90s. “Today prison reform is a movement and big companies want their association with it to be visible; earlier they kept a low profile because it could have been be construed as forced work,“ she says.
Signs of changing times are evident from the number of jails being roped in. While Spark Minda plans to set up a unit in Nagpur as well, Himalaya is scoping out Kerala, Tamil Nadu and West Bengal.
Bedi, for one, is upbeat. “I am glad companies are coming in and skilling prisoners at a low cost. Entering a prison is not risk-free, and yet they come here instead of employing elsewhere. I look at it as the glass half full.“
Prison manual, rules practices
2018: the government’s ‘Women in Prisons’ report
Calling for “prison rules and practices that treat prisoners in a dehumanised way to be abolished”, the findings of the government’s ‘Women in Prisons’ report seeks “dignity for inmates” while drawing attention to the lack of toilets and the need to link prisons to the Swachh Bharat mission.
The report which is now in public domain on the WCD website in a detailed chapter says it is not just overcrowding and delay in justice that is impacting prisons and prisoners in India, but archaic “rules” too are denying them basic human dignity like the ones which require prisoners to abstain from singing or laughing, or which make it an offence to refuse to eat food or those that allow prisoners to wear sandals only upon the sanction of the superintendent.
These telling findings on the behavioural restrictions are based on experiences gathered from certain jails visited by teams of the National Commission for Women between November 2017 and May 2018.
WCD minister Maneka Gandhi feels the report is “an initiative that should change the way prison administration perceives women inmates.”
It is recommended in the report that the state prison manuals must be updated and strictly implemented to provide basic entitlements to all women prisoners including appropriate living quarters, bedding and toilets. Highlighting that sanitation was lacking, it is recommended that prisons should be linked to local “Swachh Bharat Mission” initiative, if needed, to construct more bathrooms and toilets and to carry out repairs.
It is pointed that overcrowding can worsen hygiene conditions and health problems with even minor infections spreading quickly. Also, a large majority
(81.8%) of female prisoners fall in the menstruating age group of 18-50 years, increasing their need for proper sanitation facilities as well as access to adequate menstrual hygiene products. They are to be provided with sterilised sanitary napkins as per their requirement, but this is largely missing. Women are reportedly charged for sanitary napkins in some prisons or are only provided a set monthly number irrespective of need. This leads women to resort to using unhygienic materials such as cloth, ash, pieces of old mattresses, newspapers etc.
On the follow-up action on the report which was submitted to the MHA, it is learnt from reliable sources that the MHA is planning to identify and make some key recommendations a part of model prison manual.
“While the prescription in the prison manual is to ensure one toilet and one bathing cubicle for every 10 prisoners, this is rarely seen on the ground. There are usually a small number of bathrooms and toilets catering to a disproportionately large prison population. The National Prison Manual further estimates the daily need of water at 135 litres per inmate. In reality, there is a lack of sufficient water, which exacerbates the low levels of sanitation and hygiene. There have been reports of prisoners not being able to take a bath for multiple days,” it is stated.
2017: SC advises open jails
Emphasising the need for a change in mindset to make jails a reformative and rehabilitative place for those caught on the wrong side of law, the Supreme Court has favoured setting up of open jails where inmates will not be confined within the prison walls and allowed to live with their family members during the day and earn livelihood.
Holding that the criminal justice system in the country is based on reformation and rehabilitation of criminals, a bench of Justices Madan B Lokur and Deepak Gupta said the governments must take a humane approach towards prisoners. It directed the Centre to convene a meeting with the directors general and inspectors general of prisons of all states and UTs to examine the feasibility of setting up open jails in every district.
“The ministry of home affairs will send a communication to the authorities concerned in the state and UTs asking for their response to the idea of open prisons – whether they are willing to set up open prisons and the manner in which the open prisons could be operated. The authorities concerned should respond to the ministry preferably within a period of four weeks and the meeting will be held immediately thereafter in the first week of February, 2018,” the court said.
The court said prisoners are forced to live an inhuman life in overcrowded jails with no basic facilities and many of them were committing suicide and dying unnatural death. It said the open jail system could pave the way for them to live with dignity.
It passed the order on a plea of advocate Gaurav Agrawal who, as amicus curiae, is seeking the court’s direction to states to set up open jails in each district. The bench had taken suo motu cognisance in 2012 on pathetic conditions in 1,382 prisons across the country and has been passing directions from time to time to improve the conditions.
“This court has time and again emphasised the importance of Article 21 of the Constitution and the Right to a Life of Dignity. There must be a genuine desire to ensure that the guarantee to a Life of Dignity is provided to the extent possible even in prisons, otherwise Article 21will remain a dead letter. It must be appreciated by the state that common person does not violate the law for no reason at all. It is circumstances that lead to a situation where there is a violation,” it said.
Despite various government initiatives such as releasing of certain undertrials who have completed more than half of the imprisonment that they would get if sentenced, criminals awaiting completion of trial constitute the bulk of the country's jail population. They are crammed in jail that are operating over capacity
2015: Undertrials in India
See graphic.: Undertrials in India, some facts
Jails/ Prisons: India